نقاش:كيب نول
Living status of this person[تعديل]
We should be consistent with the English version of the article. We can't assume that the person deceased just because of IMDB, which is not reliable, or Everpedia or another wiki website. The English version treats this person as if he is still living. Why can't this version? --George Ho (مناقشه) 09:51، 27 نوفمبر 2020 (يو تى سى)
- Hi ◀George Ho:, According to Wikidata he died 21 May 2001 and the claim was removed by you. HitomiAkane - (💬 مناقشه) 10:02، 27 نوفمبر 2020 (يو تى سى)
- We can't assume that the death date is accurate and trustworthy, especially in Wikidata, can we? Right, HitomiAkane? --George Ho (مناقشه) 10:13، 27 نوفمبر 2020 (يو تى سى)
- ◀George Ho: can you consider the library of Congress as a trustworthy source? HitomiAkane - (💬 مناقشه) 10:20، 27 نوفمبر 2020 (يو تى سى)
- Unbelievable. The Library of Congress has gotten down the drains, hasn't it? It's using Wikipedia and IMDB as sources. How can you trust the Library of Congress as well when the Library is using both Wikipedia and the unreliable IMDB as a source, HitomiAkane? --George Ho (مناقشه) 10:27، 27 نوفمبر 2020 (يو تى سى)
- ◀George Ho: I'm sorry if I'm rude, but now it's your word against several sources, and according to my understanding of Wikipedia the information needs sources and the sources claims that he is died, Evin if in conclusion you think it's unreliable, so how can we solve this?, for me I made my point, now I'll leave it between the original article author and you. HitomiAkane - (💬 مناقشه) 10:50، 27 نوفمبر 2020 (يو تى سى)
- Unbelievable. The Library of Congress has gotten down the drains, hasn't it? It's using Wikipedia and IMDB as sources. How can you trust the Library of Congress as well when the Library is using both Wikipedia and the unreliable IMDB as a source, HitomiAkane? --George Ho (مناقشه) 10:27، 27 نوفمبر 2020 (يو تى سى)
- ◀George Ho: can you consider the library of Congress as a trustworthy source? HitomiAkane - (💬 مناقشه) 10:20، 27 نوفمبر 2020 (يو تى سى)
- We can't assume that the death date is accurate and trustworthy, especially in Wikidata, can we? Right, HitomiAkane? --George Ho (مناقشه) 10:13، 27 نوفمبر 2020 (يو تى سى)
◀El Gaafary: Let's discuss the person's alleged death, shall we? What about raising standards of WP:BLP? --George Ho (مناقشه) 23:55، 4 ديسمبر 2020 (يو تى سى)